Hard water is a common problem throughout the UK, particularly in areas supplied by water that has passed through limestone or chalk.
Although hard water is generally safe to drink, it can cause limescale deposits in plumbing, heating systems and household appliances.
Ion exchange water softeners provide an effective method of removing the calcium and magnesium responsible for water hardness.
In this guide, we explain how water softeners work, how to choose the correct size, the importance of regeneration and the differences between domestic and commercial systems.
What Is Hard Water?
Water hardness is primarily caused by dissolved calcium and magnesium.
As water passes through certain geological formations, it dissolves naturally occurring minerals.
When hard water is heated, calcium carbonate can precipitate, forming the familiar white or off-white deposits known as limescale.
Common signs of hard water include:
-
Limescale on taps and showerheads
-
Deposits inside kettles and water heaters
-
Reduced soap and detergent efficiency
-
Soap scum on bathroom surfaces
-
Scale accumulation in heating equipment
In commercial and industrial applications, excessive hardness can cause additional problems, particularly where water is heated or evaporated.
Scale accumulation on heat-transfer surfaces can reduce efficiency and increase maintenance requirements.
How Is Water Hardness Measured?
In the UK, water hardness is commonly expressed as milligrams per litre (mg/L) of calcium carbonate equivalent (CaCO₃).
Other measurements include German degrees (°dH), French degrees (°fH) and parts per million (ppm).
Useful conversions include:
| Hardness unit | Equivalent |
|---|---|
| 1 mg/L as CaCO₃ | 1 ppm as CaCO₃ |
| 1 German degree (°dH) | 17.85 mg/L as CaCO₃ |
| 1 French degree (°fH) | 10 mg/L as CaCO₃ |
A water hardness test can be carried out using a laboratory analysis, titration test kit or suitable hardness test strips.
Conductivity and TDS meters cannot directly measure water hardness because they respond to all dissolved ions, not just calcium and magnesium.
Before selecting a water softener, it is important to establish the actual hardness of the incoming water.
How Does an Ion Exchange Water Softener Work?
A conventional water softener contains a bed of specialist cation exchange resin.
The resin is initially charged with sodium ions.
As hard water passes through the resin, calcium and magnesium ions are attracted to the exchange sites, displacing sodium ions into the water.
The result is water with significantly reduced calcium and magnesium hardness.
Unlike salt-free scale conditioners, ion exchange softeners actually remove hardness ions.
Main Components of a Water Softener
A typical system includes:
-
Resin vessel: Contains the ion exchange resin.
-
Control valve: Directs water flow and manages regeneration.
-
Brine tank: Stores salt and prepares the brine solution.
-
Distribution system: Directs water through the resin bed.
-
Bypass arrangement: Allows the softener to be isolated when required.
The control valve may be operated by a timer or water meter, depending on the model.
What Is Water Softener Regeneration?
As water passes through the softener, the resin gradually becomes loaded with calcium and magnesium.
Eventually, its available exchange capacity is exhausted.
Regeneration restores the resin's ability to remove hardness.
The Regeneration Process
A typical regeneration cycle includes:
1. Backwash
Water flows through the resin bed to loosen and clean it.
2. Brine draw
A concentrated salt solution passes through the resin, replacing the accumulated calcium and magnesium ions with sodium ions.
3. Slow rinse
The brine continues through the resin bed, allowing the exchange process to complete.
4. Fast rinse
Fresh water removes remaining brine and displaced hardness minerals.
5. Brine refill
The control valve replenishes the brine tank with water ready for the next regeneration.
The precise sequence depends on the control valve and whether the system uses co-current or counter-current regeneration.
How Often Should a Water Softener Regenerate?
Regeneration frequency depends on:
-
Incoming water hardness
-
Volume of resin
-
Usable resin exchange capacity
-
Salt dosage
-
Daily water consumption
-
Control valve programming
A correctly sized softener should provide sufficient treated water between regenerations without allowing the resin to become exhausted during normal operation.
Understanding Softener Capacity
The total treatment capacity depends on the amount of hardness the resin can remove before regeneration is needed.
For example, a property using 500 litres of water per day with a hardness of 300 mg/L as CaCO₃ places a daily hardness load of:
500 × 300 ÷ 1,000 = 150 grams of CaCO₃ per day
The softener must have sufficient usable exchange capacity to accommodate this demand between regenerations.
The actual usable capacity depends on the resin specification, salt dose and required regeneration efficiency.
A larger softener generally provides more capacity between regenerations, but increasing resin volume alone does not necessarily improve salt efficiency.
How to Size a Water Softener
Correct sizing is essential for reliable performance.
Two separate requirements must be considered:
1. Treatment Capacity
The resin must have sufficient exchange capacity to treat the expected water consumption between regenerations.
This depends primarily on water hardness and usage.
2. Service Flow Rate
The softener must also accommodate the maximum flow required by the property or process.
A system can have sufficient treatment capacity but still be undersized hydraulically if the peak flow exceeds its recommended operating rate.
Excessive flow can reduce treatment performance, increase pressure loss and contribute to hardness leakage.
The control valve, vessel, resin bed and associated pipework must therefore be appropriately sized.
Other Important Considerations
When sizing a softener, also consider:
-
Available water pressure
-
Required treated-water hardness
-
Available space
-
Drain capacity
-
Salt storage
-
Regeneration time
-
Whether water is required continuously
Metered vs Time-Controlled Water Softeners
Water softeners can be programmed to regenerate according to water consumption or at fixed intervals.
Metered Water Softeners
Metered systems measure the volume of water treated and use this information to determine when regeneration is required.
Advantages include:
-
Better matching of regeneration to actual demand
-
Potentially lower salt consumption
-
Reduced unnecessary regeneration
-
Suitable for variable water usage
Most modern domestic and commercial softeners use metered control.
Time-Controlled Water Softeners
Time-controlled systems regenerate at a predetermined interval, regardless of the volume of water treated.
They can be appropriate where water consumption is predictable, although they may regenerate unnecessarily during periods of low demand.
The choice depends on the application, available control valve options and operating requirements.
Simplex vs Duplex Water Softeners
Another important consideration is whether to choose a single-vessel or twin-vessel system.
Simplex Water Softeners
A simplex softener contains one resin vessel.
During regeneration, that vessel is unavailable for normal softening.
Depending on the valve and installation, untreated water may be supplied through a bypass arrangement, or the water supply may be interrupted.
Simplex systems are commonly suitable for domestic properties and commercial applications where regeneration can take place during periods of low demand.
Duplex Water Softeners
A duplex softener contains two resin vessels.
In a typical alternating duplex arrangement, one vessel provides softened water while the other is regenerating or standing by.
This allows the system to maintain a continuous softened-water supply.
Duplex systems are particularly useful for:
-
Commercial laundries
-
Hotels
-
Food production
-
Industrial processes
-
Applications requiring uninterrupted softened water
Important: An alternating duplex system does not necessarily provide twice the instantaneous flow capacity of a simplex system. Peak flow is normally determined by the vessel and valve arrangement in service.
Choosing a Domestic Water Softener
For domestic applications, the main considerations are usually household water consumption, incoming hardness and available installation space.
A compact cabinet softener may be suitable for smaller properties, while larger households may benefit from a greater resin capacity.
Things to consider include:
-
Number of occupants
-
Number of bathrooms
-
Peak water demand
-
Available installation space
-
Salt storage and access
-
Regeneration settings
Most domestic systems can be programmed to regenerate overnight when demand is low.
Drinking Water Considerations
Conventional sodium-cycle water softeners increase the sodium content of treated water.
For domestic installations, UK drinking water guidance recommends retaining an unsoftened supply for drinking and cooking wherever practical.
Artificially softened water should not be used to prepare infant formula.
The softener and its installation must also comply with applicable water fittings requirements.
Choosing a Commercial Water Softener
Commercial applications often require more detailed sizing.
In addition to incoming hardness, the following should be established:
-
Average daily water consumption
-
Maximum instantaneous flow
-
Hours of operation
-
Required treated-water hardness
-
Available regeneration periods
-
Whether continuous softened water is essential
-
Scope for future expansion
For industrial applications, it is also important to consider the requirements of the equipment being supplied.
For example, boiler feedwater may require additional treatment or chemical control beyond conventional softening.
A duplex system is often preferred where interruptions to the softened-water supply would affect production or equipment operation.
Larger commercial systems may use Clack, Fleck or Autotrol control valves, with vessel and resin capacities selected according to the application.
Does Water Softening Prevent Corrosion?
Water softening is primarily a treatment for removing calcium and magnesium hardness.
It should not be regarded as a corrosion treatment.
Water hardness and corrosivity are separate characteristics.
Corrosion is influenced by several factors, including pH, alkalinity, dissolved gases, temperature and the materials used in the plumbing system.
Although softening can reduce limescale deposits, it does not automatically prevent corrosion.
In some circumstances, extensively softened water may be more aggressive towards certain plumbing materials.
Where corrosion is a concern, the complete water chemistry should be assessed rather than relying on hardness reduction alone.
Can a Water Softener Remove Iron and Manganese?
Conventional softening resin can remove certain amounts of dissolved iron and manganese under suitable conditions.
However, the system must be selected and programmed accordingly.
High concentrations or oxidised particulate iron can foul the resin, reducing its effectiveness and service life.
Specialist low-fouling resins or alternative treatment processes may be preferable where iron and manganese are significant problems.
A full water analysis is recommended before using a softener for purposes beyond conventional hardness removal.
Water Softeners from GAPS Water Treatment
At GAPS Water Treatment, we supply domestic and commercial ion exchange water softeners, including systems fitted with Clack, Fleck and Autotrol control valves.
Our range includes compact domestic softeners, larger simplex systems and automatic duplex softeners for applications requiring continuous treated water.
If you need help selecting a suitable system, email sales@gapswater.co.uk with your incoming water hardness, daily consumption, required flow rate and details of the application.
Our team can help you identify an appropriately sized water softener for your requirements.